Chemophobia or Toxic Cosmetics? Why Precaution is Not Fear
In the world of natural cosmetics, terms like “toxic-free,” “chemical-free,” or “natural” often generate controversy. Brands that promote this approach are often accused of fueling chemophobia, that is, an irrational fear of chemical products. At Banbu, we want to clarify that our position is not born of fear, but of scientific evidence, the precautionary principle, and ethics in formulation.
We want to explain, in a technical and documented way, why we choose to exclude certain ingredients from our formulas—even if they are legally permitted—and how we avoid falling into alarmist or misleading claims.
Everything is chemistry, but not all chemistry is the same
First of all, we do not promote chemophobia. We know that everything that surrounds us, natural or synthetic, is composed of chemical substances. Water is a chemical substance (H₂O), just like vitamin C (ascorbic acid) or formaldehyde. For this reason, we do not consider “chemical” to be synonymous with “bad.” What we analyze is the toxicological profile, the context of use, cumulative exposure, and the susceptibility of certain population groups.
Why we eliminate certain ingredients: scientific evidence, not fear
In our formulation philosophy, we apply the precautionary principle, especially regarding substances that present scientific controversies, ongoing regulatory evaluations, or potential risks to human health or the environment. Some examples:
1. Endocrine disruptors
The endocrine disruptors (EDCs) are compounds capable of interfering with the hormonal system, even at very low doses. The World Health Organization (WHO) and the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) published a key report where they classify exposure to EDCs as an emerging global threat to public health【1】.
Studies such as Vandenberg et al. (2012) demonstrate that many EDCs do not follow a traditional dose-response curve, which means that levels considered “safe” according to classical toxicology may not be safe at all【2】. The EU has identified at least 28 substances suspected of being EDCs in cosmetics, and although their use is not yet prohibited, they are under evaluation by the SCCS and the European Commission【3】.
2. CMR substances (Carcinogenic, Mutagenic or Toxic for Reproduction)
Some ingredients used in conventional cosmetics are classified as CMR substances under the REACH regulation (Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006). Although the European Cosmetics Regulation 1223/2009 restricts the use of CMR substances, there are exceptions and delays in updating the lists. At Banbu, we decided not to include any substance with suspicions of chronic toxicity.
3. Controversial preservatives
Substances like triclosan, formaldehyde releasers (DMDM Hydantoin, Imidazolidinyl Urea), or certain parabens have been progressively banned or restricted by European health authorities. However, others remain permitted. Our policy is to exclude all those with a history of allergic effects, long-term toxicity, or environmental bioaccumulation, even if they are not legally prohibited【4】【5】.
The cocktail effect: a gap in regulation
One of the main problems of the current regulatory approach is that it evaluates ingredients individually, without taking into account the combined exposure to multiple substances (cocktail effect). The EFSA and the ECHA have recognized this limitation on repeated occasions【6】.
Furthermore, toxicity studies are generally performed on healthy adults, without considering the vulnerability of pregnant women, children, people with hormonal disorders, or chronic diseases. For many people, trust in a cosmetic is not based solely on its efficacy, but on the absence of ingredients that may pose a risk in their personal health context.
Responsible information ≠ fear-based marketing
At Banbu, we believe that the consumer has the right to know not only what is in a product, but also what we have decided not to include and why. This is not fear, but transparency.
We do not claim that conventional cosmetics are inherently toxic. We recognize the regulatory advances, quality controls, and toxicological studies that support their safety. But we also recognize that current standards are neither infallible nor static, and that there are margins of scientific uncertainty that deserve honest communication, without drama, but without euphemisms.
Our alternative is based on:
-
Formulation according to stricter standards than legal ones (COSMOS, EWG Verified).
-
Selection of ingredients based on their toxicological profile, not just their origin.
-
Inclusion of scientific literature in our formulation decisions.
-
Use of matrices free of known allergens and suitable for sensitive skin.
Conclusion: educate, don't scare
Safe cosmetics are not just those that pass regulatory filters. They are also those that take into account the latest scientific findings, respect the diversity of users and their specific needs, and opt for simple, clean, and ethical formulas.
At Banbu, we do not fuel chemophobia, but we also do not accept a complacent view that does not acknowledge the current limits of the regulatory system. We prefer to speak about science, evidence, and responsibility.
Because true consumer freedom begins when you have all the information to decide.
References
-
WHO/UNEP (2013). State of the Science of Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals 2012. World Health Organization.
-
Vandenberg, L. N., et al. (2012). "Hormones and endocrine-disrupting chemicals: low-dose effects and nonmonotonic dose responses." Endocrine Reviews, 33(3), 378–455.
-
European Commission. Priority List of Substances for Evaluation Regarding Endocrine Disruption.
-
Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products.
-
ECHA & EFSA (2020). Guidance on harmonised assessment of risk from combined exposure to multiple chemicals.